[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Sheflug] Bad Information



Hello all.
 
Heres a new topic for discussion, if you like.
 
I was just trawling comp.os.linux, and came across a query from someone asking what POSIX is. The only reply they got was that 'POSIX is some kind of alternative shell similar in many ways to Bash, with a few nuances of its own'.
 
I did point the guy to www.whatis.com/posix, but the problem is this:
 
With all this information freely floating around, people are likely to latch onto the first instance of an answer they encounter. If this means that they will be forever wrong, no matter. They don't know that the information is duff.
 
As it happens, Linux has an excellent community of techy people willing and able to help, but some very disillusioned souls are finding themselves at completely the wrong end of the stick.
 
I have encountered people in newsgroups assuming things like:
    POSIX is a type of shell (see above)
    You need to reboot to change the screen resolution in X, change the hostname, anything, in fact!!
    If you use LILO, Windows and all other OS' will be deleted
    Windows software will run 'out-of-the-box'
    You need DirectX to run anything vaguely multimedia
    They've made a mistake because IE4/5 is not there when they run X!!
 
As you can tell, most of this are simply ridiculous, but being a newbie once myself, I know that if you assume something like this, and no-one tells you otherwise, you can get in bother.
 
On the one hand, then, newbies can get a lot of help from others more experienced, but on the other hand, they are open to any old rubbish anyone wishes to (authoritively) tell them.
 
Perhaps the role of Linux User Groups must grow beyond 'a meeting place for those interested to chat and go down the pub' to portals into the Linux world for anyone interested, seasoned pro or newcomer alike.
 
Just a thought.
 
Craig
 
- - - - - - - - - - - -
If you think this is a load of rubbish,
you should read my college reports!!
- - - - - - - - - - - -